SOX 404: Before, Now and After

The Second Opinion

The U.S. Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC) proposes to stop requiring the auditor’s opinion on internal control for 1,596 companies. We provide our view on how this is likely to evolve and what it means for management and audit committees.

20, October 2026

The U.S. Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC) proposes to stop requiring the auditor’s opinion on internal control for 1,596 companies. We provide our view on how this is likely to evolve and what it means for management and audit committees.

Executive Summary

1,596

Registrants the SEC estimates would be newly exempt from the auditor’s attestation on internal control: 26.7% of all registrants

80

Out of 117 commenters addressing the attestation, 80 called the exemption too broad (16 voicing concern rather than outright objection) or said it should not be expanded

0

Out of 11 audit firms commenting, 0 endorsed the $2 billion threshold as proposed; 10 questioned the five-year on-ramp

58

Out of 75 commenters addressing the five-year on-ramp, 58 rejected or questioned a uniform 60 months

Many finance leaders have read the SEC’s filer status proposal of May 19, 2026 (Release No. 33-11419, Enhancement of Emerging Growth Company Accommodations and Simplification of Filer Status for Reporting Companies) as a cost saving. The large accelerated filer threshold would rise from $700 million to $2 billion of public float, every new registrant would have five years of seasoning, and the auditor’s opinion on internal control would no longer be required for 1,596 companies.

The public comment record suggests the matter is less settled. It holds 192 entries from 174 distinct commenters, and this paper draws on a review of each one. We trace how Section 404 of the Sarbanes-Oxley Act (SOX 404) reached this point, summarize what the SEC has heard, and consider what finance leaders may wish to do before a final rule.

?

First, how has SOX 404 evolved, and what has it delivered?

The requirement was put in place between 2002 and 2005 and has been scaled or narrowed four times since; the proposal would be the fifth. The $700 million threshold set in 2005 has not moved; it captured 18% of companies on US markets at adoption and captures 35.4% of registrants today. Over the same period, restatements fell, and the SEC staff concluded from the research that auditor testing brought out control deficiencies management had not disclosed, though neither can be credited to SOX 404 alone.

(Refer Section 1: How SOX 404 Evolved)

?

Second, what did commenters tell the SEC?

Of the 117 commenters who addressed the attestation, 80 said the exemption is too broad or should not be expanded, 16 of those 80 raised it as a caution rather than an outright objection, and 31 supported it or sought a wider one.

Who commented also mattered. Every company, both exchanges, and every business trade association that took a position supported the exemption. No accounting firm endorsed the $2 billion threshold as proposed, and all 24 investors and investor advocates that addressed the exemption called it too broad or opposed any expansion.

(Refer Sections 3 and 4: What the SEC Heard; Two Questions Left Open)

?

Third, where could the final rule move?

No final rule has been adopted. The comment letters suggest where it could change: the five-year on-ramp for very large new listings, a second test beside public float, and relief for companies that cross today’s thresholds while the rule is pending.

(Refer Section 5: How the Final Rule Could Change)

?

Fourth, will this bring the mid-market back?

In our view, the proposal would lower the cost of staying public but do little to change the decision to go public, as most companies making that decision are already exempt. The proposed release gives no estimate of additional listings.

(Refer Section 6: Capital Markets and the Mid-Market)

?

Fifth, what should finance leaders do before a final rule?

Companies may wish to confirm their status under both rule sets, base the saving on the auditor’s own fee proposal, and take the decision to retain, discontinue, or replace the auditor’s attestation to the audit committee with evidence. Section 7 sets out eight decisions for the SOX program leader.

(Refer Section 7: Actions to Consider Before a Final Rule)

Uniqus Point of View: when management’s assessment stands alone

Much of the comment record debates where the threshold should sit; finance leaders face a different question. Once the auditor’s opinion is optional, management’s assessment under SOX 404(a) becomes the only report on internal control an investor receives. The proposal changes neither that assessment nor the certifications that accompany it.

We would expect the core of the proposal to survive, with changes at the margins. Companies below $2 billion of float that obtain the attestation today should prepare for a year in which it becomes optional.

That decision rests with the audit committee, and it should be grounded in evidence before a lender, underwriter or investor raises the question.


What this means for you

AC

If you are

Audit committee chair and the committee

What changes for you The auditor’s opinion on internal control would become the committee’s choice rather than a requirement.
The decision in front of you Retain, discontinue, or replace, recorded on evidence before the next audit plan is approved.

See 7.1

CFO

If you are

CFO and chief accounting officer signing 302 and 906 certifications

What changes for you Certifications and management’s 404(a) assessment are unchanged; the audit fee and filing deadlines may change.
The decision in front of you Base the saving on the auditor’s fee proposal, and decide how to explain the choice.

See 4.1 , 7

SOX

If you are

SOX program leader and chief audit executive

What changes for you No external test of management’s conclusion, though the auditor must still understand, and may test, controls.
The decision in front of you Define the evidence standard for scope, sampling, tester independence and deficiency evaluation.

See 7.2

TRS

If you are

Treasurer and investor relations lenders, rating agencies, holders

What changes for you Covenants, bank regulators and investors may still expect the auditor’s opinion.
The decision in front of you Identify who else relies on it, and prepare a response for the first investor who asks.

See 7

IPO

If you are

Initial public offering (IPO) candidate and its sponsors

What changes for you Every new registrant, not only emerging growth companies, has five years before the attestation can apply.
The decision in front of you Build controls to the standard the company will need in year six, not year one.

See 6.1

FPI

If you are

Foreign private issuers listed on multiple exchanges

What changes for you No change on Form 20-F; the attestation still applies from $75 million of float.
The decision in front of you Build one control framework to the most demanding market it reports in.

See 7.2

Source: Uniqus analysis of SEC Release 33-11419 and comment file S7-2026-18.


How SOX 404 Evolved

Introduced between 2002 and 2005 and has been scaled or narrowed four times since; the proposal would be the fifth.

SOX 404 has two parts. Under 404(a), management assesses internal control over financial reporting and reports its conclusion; under 404(b), the auditor attests to that assessment.

The attestation has never applied to everyone, and it has been scaled or narrowed four times. In 2007 the SEC issued guidance for management and the Public Company Accounting Oversight Board (PCAOB) issued a risk-based audit standard; in 2010 Congress exempted non-accelerated filers from the auditor’s attestation by statute, after the SEC had repeatedly deferred it for them. The JOBS Act exempted emerging growth companies in 2012, and in 2020 the SEC removed issuers eligible to be smaller reporting companies with revenue under $100 million from accelerated and large accelerated filer status.

Exhibit 1 — The life of SOX 404, 2002 to 2026

INTRODUCED, 2002 TO 2005: THE REQUIREMENT TAKES EFFECT

2002

Sarbanes-Oxley enacted; accelerated filer threshold set at $75 million of float

2004

First auditor attestations, from accelerated filers

2005

Large accelerated filer threshold set at $700 million

SCALED OR NARROWED, 2007 TO 2026: THE PROPOSAL WOULD BE THE FIFTH

2007

SEC guidance for management; PCAOB risk-based AS 5

2010

Dodd-Frank: non-accelerated filers exempt by statute

2012

JOBS Act: emerging growth companies exempt for up to five years

2020

Issuers with revenue under $100 million leave accelerated status

2026

Proposal: $2 billion threshold; 60 months for every new registrant

Who sits above the large accelerated filer threshold

2005, at adoption

18%

of companies on US markets; “nearly 95 percent” of float

2024, same $700 million threshold

35.4%

of registrants; 98.8% of float

Proposed $2 billion threshold

19.2%

of registrants; 93.5% of float

Source: SEC Release 33-11419 (May 19, 2026), pp. 12, 20 to 34, 40 to 42, 150 and 207; SEC Release 33-8392 for the 2004 compliance date; Uniqus analysis. The 2004 entry is the first fiscal year end (on or after November 15, 2004) for which accelerated filers provided the auditor’s attestation. Shares are the SEC’s estimates; the 2005 figures are shares of companies on the NYSE, Amex, Nasdaq, OTC Bulletin Board and Pink Sheets and of their float, and “nearly 95 percent” is the SEC’s wording, so the 2005 and 2024 columns are not on the same base. The $2 billion figures also apply the proposed 60-month seasoning and two-year test; with today’s 12-month seasoning the count would be 1,234 (20.6% of registrants).

The $700 million threshold set in 2005 has not moved since; it captured 18% of companies on US markets at adoption and captures 35.4% of registrants today. The SEC did not index it; adjusted for consumer prices the threshold would be $1.15 billion, and tracking the S&P 500 Index, $3.85 billion. Instead, the SEC chose $2 billion to restore coverage of “nearly 95 percent” of public float, and estimates that the new threshold covers 93.5%.

1.1 What the record shows

The SEC’s own tables show the control record under each regime. From 2021 to 2024, management reported ineffective controls at 5.2% of large accelerated filers, 15.7% of accelerated filers and 41.8% of non-accelerated filers.

Exhibit 2 — The control record by filer status

Source: SEC Release 33-11419, EA Tables 5, 6 and 7 (pp. 139 to 142) and EA Table 2 (p. 132), SEC staff analysis of Audit Analytics data. Categories are 2024 filer status under the current rules. EA Tables 5 and 6 include emerging growth companies in each column; of 757 accelerated filers, 125 are emerging growth companies and are not subject to attestation. Restatements are those correcting errors material to previously issued financial statements; in that table the accelerated and non-accelerated columns exclude emerging growth companies, whose rate was 14.7% (31.4% in fiscal 2021, when restatements coincided with the SEC staff’s statement on special purpose acquisition company (SPAC) warrants). Differences reflect company size as well as regime.

Size explains part of that gradient, and the SEC reads its restatement table cautiously, noting that the rate for non-accelerated filers is “only slightly higher” than for accelerated filers and that the non-accelerated group holds more low- or zero-revenue issuers, which restate less often. The gap is widest on persistence, with 24.9% of non-accelerated filers reporting ineffective controls in all four years, against 4.2% of accelerated filers.

Where the attestation is optional, few companies obtain it; the SEC estimates that less than six percent of exempt registrants did so voluntarily in 2024.

1.2 What the second opinion has delivered

Cost is only one side of the ledger; on the other, the SEC’s 2011 staff study concluded that auditor testing “has generally resulted in the disclosure of internal control deficiencies” that management had not previously disclosed, and that the attestation “appears to have a positive impact on the informativeness of internal control disclosures and financial reporting quality”.

Restatements rose in the first three years of the Act and have declined since. The Center for Audit Quality, the audit profession’s policy body, reports a 60% decline from 2006 to 2009 and a further fall from 858 in 2013 to 402 in 2022. Ideagen Audit Analytics, counting from the same database without the Center’s adjustment for blank-check companies, recorded 434 in 2023, 477 in 2024 and 391 in 2025, the second-lowest year in its 20-year database after 2020.

Exhibit 3 — Restatements announced by SEC registrants, 2013 to 2025

Source: Center for Audit Quality, Financial Restatement Trends in the United States: 2013 to 2022 (June 2024), p. 15, for 2013 to 2022; Ideagen Audit Analytics, Financial Restatements reports (June 2025 for 2023; May 2026 for 2024 and 2025) for 2022* and 2023 to 2025. Both draw on the Audit Analytics database and count reissuance and revision restatements in the year announced. The Center’s figures exclude 1,155 restatements by blank-check companies that followed the SEC staff’s April 2021 statement on warrants; Ideagen’s include them (13 in 2025; 2023 and 2024 not published), so 2022 is shown on both bases and the two segments should not be read as one line. Ideagen revises counts as late filings arrive; 2025 is as first reported. The fall cannot be credited to SOX 404 alone.

Those closest to the work saw value in it, though on average not enough to outweigh the cost. The proposing release says respondents to a 2008 and 2009 survey of corporate insiders found the benefits to outweigh the costs, “especially as they gained experience with SOX 404(b)”. The underlying study, of 2,901 insiders, is less favorable, finding that on average respondents did not judge the benefits to outweigh the costs, though perceived net benefits were higher where an auditor attested and rose with experience.

Compliance costs also fell after 2007, when the PCAOB issued Auditing Standard No. 5 and the SEC issued its guidance for management.

The SEC itself notes a wider benefit: SOX 404(b) “may play a role in improving overall investor confidence, encouraging investment in public markets”. None of this proves cause, since the Act also created the PCAOB, audit committee independence rules and officer certifications. The proposing release also cites a 2024 working paper that found no decline in internal control or financial reporting quality at issuers exempted in 2020, and says auditor testing “may have fewer benefits” at the larger companies now affected.

What the record does show is what would be given up: an independent test that, in the research the SEC staff reviewed in 2011, brought out deficiencies management had not disclosed. That study covered companies with $75 million to $250 million of float and recommended against widening the exemption.


What the SEC Proposed

A $2 billion threshold, a five-year seasoning period, and no auditor’s opinion below either.

Element Today Proposed
Large accelerated filer threshold $700 million of public float $2 billion of public float
How float is measured Share price on the last business day of the second fiscal quarter Average closing price over the last 10 trading days of that quarter, times non-affiliate shares at quarter end
Moving in or out One measurement; exit below $560 million for large accelerated status and $60 million for accelerated status, or on qualifying under the revenue test Two consecutive years above or below the threshold; no separate exit level
Seasoning before the status applies 12 months of reporting 60 months, whatever the company’s size
Management’s assessment, 404(a) Required of all Unchanged
Foreign private issuers on Form 20-F Attestation from $75 million of float Unchanged: $75 million of worldwide float, measured on a single day

Under the proposal, status would change only after two years on the same side of the threshold. For example, a calendar-year company with 60 months of reporting whose float first reaches $2 billion on June 30, 2027 would not be a large accelerated filer for fiscal 2027, but would become one for fiscal 2028 if its float is still $2 billion or more on June 30, 2028; a large accelerated filer would likewise need two years below $2 billion to leave, with no lower exit level like today’s $560 million. The transition is the exception: when a final rule takes effect, a current large accelerated filer below $2 billion in either of the two prior years becomes non-accelerated.

2.1 The filer categories, today and under the proposal

Filer status determines three things: how fast a company must file, how much it must disclose, and whether its auditor attests to internal control. Today five overlapping categories can apply. The proposal would keep two main categories, large accelerated and non-accelerated, and add a sub-category for the smallest companies.

Category Who it is today What it carries today Under the proposal
Large accelerated filer Public float of $700 million or more at the end of the second quarter; 12 months of reporting; one annual report filed; not eligible as a smaller reporting company on the revenue test 10-K in 60 days, 10-Q in 40; auditor’s attestation; full disclosure $2 billion or more at each of the last two second-quarter ends and 60 months of reporting; obligations unchanged
Accelerated filer Float of $75 million to under $700 million, with the same other conditions 10-K in 75 days, 10-Q in 40; attestation unless an emerging growth company Eliminated; becomes non-accelerated
Non-accelerated filer Not defined in the rules: every other registrant 10-K in 90 days, 10-Q in 45; no attestation Any issuer that is not large accelerated; same deadlines; no attestation; scaled disclosure, with some exceptions; must disclose material unresolved staff comments, which is new for them
Smaller reporting company Float under $250 million, or revenue under $100 million with float under $700 million Scaled disclosure: two years of financial statements and management’s discussion and analysis (MD&A) instead of three, lighter executive pay disclosure Eliminated; its accommodations pass to non-accelerated filers
Emerging growth company Revenue under $1.235 billion, for up to five years after IPO No attestation; scaled disclosure; deferred adoption of new accounting standards Retained by statute; the SEC expects reliance on it to be unnecessary in most circumstances. Only emerging growth companies keep confidential draft registration statements and the exemption from critical audit matters
Small non-accelerated filer Does not exist Not applicable New: total assets of $35 million or less on the last day of the second fiscal quarter in each of the last two years, ending once assets exceed $35 million at both; 10-K in 120 days, 10-Q in 50. The SEC estimates 1,072 companies

Source: SEC Release 33-11419, pp. 9 to 13, 20 to 21, 28 to 33, 37 to 48, 55 to 56, 61, 66 to 69, 81 to 84, 87 to 88, 96 and 103 to 106. Smaller reporting and emerging growth status sit on top of the other categories today. Public float is the market value of common equity held by non-affiliates.

A change of status therefore affects more than the attestation. A large accelerated filer that becomes non-accelerated gains 30 days on its Form 10-K and five on its Form 10-Q, may present two years of financial statements where it now presents three, and would be exempt from say-on-pay, say-on-frequency and golden-parachute votes, an emerging growth company accommodation the SEC proposes to extend to all non-accelerated filers.

It could also omit risk factors from Forms 10-K and 10-Q, market risk disclosure, the compensation discussion and analysis, pay ratio and pay versus performance. The option to defer new accounting standards to private-company dates is limited to a filer’s first five years after registration, so most large accelerated filers that change status would not have it.

The SEC estimates that large accelerated filers would fall from 2,115 to 1,146, or from 35.4% to 19.2% of registrants, while still holding 93.5% of public float. In all, 1,596 registrants, 60% of those that obtain an attestation today, would be newly exempt, comprising 964 current large accelerated filers and 632 accelerated filers. The SEC could not classify the other five of today’s 2,115 large accelerated filers because their float data is missing.

Two groups gain less than the headline suggests. Banks are counted in the 1,596, but an insured bank with $5 billion or more of total assets remains subject to the Federal Deposit Insurance Corporation’s (FDIC’s) attestation requirement under 12 CFR Part 363, a threshold in effect since January 1, 2026. The FDIC rule applies to the bank, not the holding company, so a holding company that discontinues the attestation may still need one for its bank; the SEC estimates that 87 of 153 banking large accelerated filers would become non-accelerated.

Foreign private issuers filing on Form 20-F or 40-F remain outside the new categories and retain today’s $75 million trigger, measured on a single day.

Where the rule stands

Source: SEC Release 33-11419 and sec.gov docket S7-2026-18, as of October 5, 2026.


What the SEC Heard

The letters divide between those who pay for assurance and those who rely on it or provide it.

On October 5, 2026, the docket held 192 entries, the latest dated September 8, 2026. Excluding SEC staff memoranda, a roundtable transcript and duplicates leaves 174 distinct commenters, of whom 117 addressed the attestation and 57 did not mention it.

Exhibit 4 — Where 117 commenters stood on the attestation exemption

 

Source: Uniqus coding of every entry on SEC comment file S7-2026-18 as posted on October 5, 2026; the method is set out in “How we reviewed the letters”. Not counted: three letters posted October 5 to 8, 2026, from a biotech chief financial officer (CFO) in support, an audit firm already counted that restates its position, and a former PCAOB staff member who calls the exemption too broad. The 6 with no position are business associations 1, venture capital and policy groups 2, academics 2 and individuals 1. The Texas Society of CPAs letter could not be opened on the docket and was read from the society’s website. “Too broad” means the commenter accepts some widening of the exemption and objects to its extent; 16 of those 33 raise it as a caution rather than an outright objection. Positions are on the exemption, not on the $2 billion figure.

Support came mainly from those who bear the cost: companies, their associations, both exchanges and most securities lawyers who commented. Opposition was led by investors and individual commenters, joined by academics and most of the firms and professional bodies that provide assurance. Among investors and investor advocates, all 24 that addressed the attestation called the exemption too broad or opposed any expansion.

Thirty-three commenters accepted that the threshold should rise but objected to its extent; 26 proposed another threshold or test.

3.1 The audit profession’s positions

Twelve firms from the audit profession commented: 11 of the 20 largest US accounting firms by revenue (2026 INSIDE Public Accounting list), including the four largest, and one advisory firm that does not audit. Neither the American Institute of Certified Public Accountants (AICPA), the Institute of Internal Auditors, Financial Executives International, nor the Institute of Management Accountants commented.

None of the twelve firms endorsed the $2 billion threshold as proposed. Based on what each letter leads with, nine said the exemption is, or may be, too broad. Exhibit 4 counts all twelve as too broad, as those three also seek a narrower exemption.

What they told the SEC How many What they asked for, and what it means for you
The threshold is too high; an alternative is named. Five: four audit firms and the advisory firm Each named an alternative: retain today’s $700 million threshold; a threshold of about $1.1 billion; inflation-adjusted thresholds; a revenue limit of $1.235 billion beside float; or retention after a recent material weakness. If the SEC adopts any, some companies with $700 million to $2 billion of float would keep the attestation.
The exempt group may be too wide; no number is named. Four audit firms A second look at the number of companies exempted, a test beyond public float alone, and refreshed PCAOB guidance on auditing internal control, not on the PCAOB’s September 30, 2026 standard-setting agenda. Even firms with no alternative question the breadth, adding weight to a second test beside float.
The evidence is not yet sufficient to decide. Two audit firms Consult investors first, and revise the cost estimate to include control work auditors must still perform. The SEC’s estimated savings may be overstated.
The market should decide. One audit firm Make the attestation optional for most issuers. Even this supporter suggested the SEC consider a threshold below $2 billion.

Three points from the firms’ letters that bear on planning

  • The net saving may be smaller than the fee suggests. Seven audit firms said the financial statement audit would absorb part of the work, as auditors must still understand controls and often test them or do more substantive work.
  • Five years may be too long for very large new listings. Ten of the eleven audit firms questioned a flat 60-month on-ramp.
  • Fewer firms may retain the capability. One firm estimates, “based on current data,” that only six firms would likely perform integrated audits for ten or more issuers.

How we reviewed the letters

Approach. Every letter was coded twice, independently, with artificial intelligence (AI) under the direction of Uniqus professionals, and every difference was resolved by a third reading of the letter. Each code rests on a quoted passage. Every quotation was checked against the page of the filed letter.

What is counted. Each distinct filer counts once, including a letter with 115 signatories, most of them academics, and a joint letter from 49 organizations. A position reflects only what a letter says about the attestation; one that never mentions SOX 404(b) is recorded as silent.


Two Questions Left Open

What the exemption may save, and how investors may respond.

4.1 The likely cost saving

The SEC’s proposal cannot isolate the attestation fee because companies disclose only total audit fees. Its estimate instead rests on $202,500 of outside cost and 375 internal hours per annual report, a 2020 figure adjusted for inflation.

Issuers that commented put the figure higher. One listed company cited by Nasdaq and one biotech CFO each put it at $500,000 to $1 million a year, a range spanning the two highest estimates in the proposing release, $759,000 and $800,000. A governance association’s member survey points the same way.

Exhibit 5 — The SEC’s estimate and companies’ estimates

Source: SEC Release 33-11419, pp. 153 to 155, 215 and 218, including Government Accountability Office (GAO) report GAO-25-107500; comment letters of Nasdaq, Inc. (p. 4), Avalo Therapeutics (web comment), and the Society for Corporate Governance (p. 7; its member survey “attracted nearly 50 responses”, p. 1, note 1). The CFO’s letter reads “between $500-$1M annually”. In the survey, 21% of respondents put the annual cost at $500,000 to $1 million and 18% at $1 million to $5 million; among those expecting to become exempt, 23% and 8%. The release also cites estimates on other bases, from $73,165 in audit fees for companies under $300 million of market capitalization to approximately $800,000 all-in for a sample of four to seven biotech companies. GAO measured a median rise of $219,000 (13%) in the year companies began the attestation and treats it as a proxy for its cost. The SEC’s figure is an average across registrants and the companies’ figures are individual reports, so the exhibit shows a gap between them, not an error in either.

The same survey suggests that the saving companies expect is smaller than the cost they report. Taken together, its two highest cost bands put the attestation’s cost at $500,000 or more a year for 39% of respondents, yet only 3% expect non-accelerated status to save them more than $500,000, while 55% could not quantify the saving at all (pp. 6 and 7).

Neither set of figures answers the controller’s central question, which is what the financial statement audit will cost once the auditor no longer tests controls for a separate opinion. In our view, only a company-specific fee proposal can answer it.

4.2 How investors may respond

Opposing commenters argue that investors will price the missing attestation into a higher cost of capital. The figures they cite trace largely to one 2009 study that measured how the cost of equity moved when auditor-tested reports showed controls weakening or being remediated; it did not study the removal of the auditor’s opinion. The only study we found in the comment letters that measured the cost of capital after an actual exemption, of issuers with revenue under $100 million in 2020, found no significant difference; the SEC cites the same study on reporting quality.

Companies appear undecided too. In the same survey, 12% of respondents said they would likely retain the attestation voluntarily and 15% were confident they would discontinue it; 52% said it would depend on investor demand.

Nasdaq, Inc., comment letter, p. 4

“One listed company estimated that it spent between $500,000 and $1 million annually with independent auditors to comply with this disclosure obligation and observed that such expenses could be better deployed on research & development.”

Ohio Public Employees Retirement System, comment letter, p. 9

“Without an independent “gatekeeper,” management’s assessment is inherently less credible – in effect, investors are being asked to trust the numbers with one fewer check on the system that produced them.”

In our view, both can be true. The first speaks to the attestation’s cost; the second, to its purpose.


How the Final Rule Could Change

The Commission may adopt the proposal as written. If it changes course, the comment letters suggest where.

Exhibit 6 — Alternative thresholds and the companies that would remain in scope

  • $1.15bn CPI-adjusted $700m
  • $2bn the proposal
  • $3.85bn tracking the S&P 500
  • 16 commenters wanted it lower
  • 18 supported $2bn
  • 4 wanted it higher

Source: SEC Release 33-11419, p. 42 (inflation-adjusted and S&P 500-proportionate lines) and EA Table 13, p. 207; Uniqus coding of comment file S7-2026-18 for the 51 commenters that addressed the $2 billion figure. EA Table 13 applies the proposal’s 60-month seasoning and two-year test at each float line, so its $700 million row (1,665 large accelerated filers holding 95.2% of float) is not comparable with today’s 2,115 holding 98.8%. Shares are of total public float.

Element What commenters said What to watch for
Five-year on-ramp 58 of the 75 commenters that addressed it rejected or questioned a uniform 60 months A shorter period, or size-based exits like those for emerging growth companies
Float as the sole test 14 commenters proposed a revenue test or asked the SEC to consider one A revenue limit at or near $1.235 billion
The $2 billion level Of the 50 that took a view on the figure, 18 supported it, 16 wanted it lower, 4 higher and 12 opposed any increase A figure from $1.15 billion to $2 billion, or indexing (such as inflation indexing, market-capitalization/index growth, etc.)
Crossing a threshold in 2026 One association and two issuers asked for interim relief; none is proposed A grace period, or status held until the final rule
Foreign private issuers Kept at $75 million; law firms asked for parity, now or in the foreign issuer rulemaking A statement that the exclusion is transitional
Disclosure of whether the auditor attested Five commenters asked that companies disclose whether an attestation was obtained A required statement on whether the auditor attested

Commenters agree most on the on-ramp, which would not affect a seasoned mid-market company; a second test or a lower threshold would. The counts show where the arguments lie, not the vote.


Capital Markets and the Mid-Market

The proposal would lower the cost of remaining public, but the decision to go public depends largely on other factors.

The proposal’s stated purpose is to encourage more companies to go and stay public. The decline is well documented, with the number of companies listed on US exchanges falling from 8,090 in 1996 to 3,908 in 2025.

Exhibit 7 — Fewer listed companies alongside ample IPO capital

Source: World Federation of Exchanges via World Bank, indicator CM.MKT.LDOM.NO, “Listed domestic companies, total”, United States, updated July 13, 2026: companies listed on US exchanges at year end, including foreign companies listed only there and excluding investment funds and holding companies, so a foreign company also listed at home is not counted; 1996 is the peak. Renaissance Capital, US IPO Market 2025 Annual Review (December 18, 2025), and Q3 2026 Quarterly Review (October 1, 2026): IPOs and direct listings of at least $50 million of market value, excluding closed-end funds, SPACs and, from 2026, unit offerings. 2023 is as restated in Renaissance’s quarterly series (earlier reviews: 108 IPOs, $19.4 billion); 2026 is January to September, as restated in the Q3 2026 review. The two offerings are SpaceX ($75.0 billion, June 2026) and SK hynix ($26.5 billion of American depositary receipts, July 2026; its primary listing remains in Seoul).

The SEC is careful not to quantify the effect. The proposed release gives no estimate of additional listings and states that the “magnitude and direction of the effect is difficult to predict”. It also notes that approximately 88% of 2024 IPOs, excluding funds and direct listings, were by emerging growth companies, which already have the exemption for up to five years.

The comment letters do not fill that gap. Supporters argue that listings will follow, but none estimate how many. The academic whose study the proposing release cites on the JOBS Act’s effect on IPOs supports the proposal, including the five-year on-ramp, while warning them that the wider exemption is “not costless”, and wrote:

Professor Michael Dambra, University at Buffalo, comment letter, p. 2

“While I do not expect the regulation to increase IPO activity in the United States, our research indicates that scaling back the burdens of being public enhances the frequency and efficiency of corporate investment and innovation …”

Much of the research the SEC cites points to other causes, notably abundant private capital and small companies choosing to be acquired. Three of the authors of one of those studies, updating it in 2025 with a co-author, date the US listing gap to 1999, three years before Sarbanes-Oxley, and find that it widened only slowly through 2023.

The listing data is consistent with this. By the end of 2001, before the Act took effect, the count had fallen from 8,090 to 6,177, or 46% of the total decline to 2025.

Capital also remains available. US IPOs raised $147.5 billion in the first nine months of 2026, more than in all of 2021, though two offerings account for $101.5 billion of it.

6.1 Implications for mid-market companies

For a listed company with less than $2 billion of float that has the attestation today, the benefits are direct: lower audit fees and less risk of a share price move carrying it across a threshold.

For a private company considering a listing, the change is narrower than it may appear. A candidate small enough to qualify as an emerging growth company already has up to five years. The new relief is for candidates too large for that status, and one audit firm described the companies between its preferred threshold and $2 billion as generally “large and seasoned public companies rather than the private companies weighing whether to enter the public markets” (comment letter, p. 4).

Two findings point the other way, both from the only data set in the comment letters built on the affected companies (Professors Rajgopal, Wong and Zhao, comment letter, pp. 2 to 4). Auditors reported ineffective controls at 12.8% of companies with $250 million to $700 million of float and 8.5% at $700 million to $2 billion, compared with 3.8% above $2 billion. The typical newly exempted company is followed by 4 to 6 analysts, compared with 12 for companies that remain in scope.

For foreign issuers, the proposal may work against its own purpose, since a foreign private issuer on Form 20-F would still need the auditor’s attestation from $75 million of worldwide float, unless it is an emerging growth company, while a domestic competitor would be exempt up to $2 billion; the SEC is deferring relief until it completes the eligibility review it opened in June 2025. The proposed release acknowledges this “could result in competitive disadvantages”. One international law firm wrote of the wider gap between the domestic and foreign issuer regimes: “We believe this gap will make U.S. listings significantly less attractive for foreign issuers, thereby reducing the investment opportunities available to U.S. investors” (Linklaters LLP, comment letter, p. 2).

Uniqus Point of View: an option, not a saving

In our view, the proposal lowers the cost of staying public but does little to change the decision to go public. Most companies making that decision are already exempt, and the main reasons companies stay private, namely ample private capital, valuation and litigation exposure, are unaffected.

For a mid-market company, the appeal of a US listing rests on valuation, liquidity and research coverage, and a control record that withstands independent testing supports all three.

The exemption is an option to be priced, not a saving to be booked.


Actions to Consider Before a Final Rule

Eight decisions for SOX program leaders, in the order they arise.

The first step is to locate the company. Three questions decide where it lands, and only one of the three outcomes calls for action now.

Exhibit 8 — Determining filer status under the proposal

Until a final rule takes effect, the current thresholds still apply. A company that crossed a threshold on June 30, 2026, needs the attestation for fiscal 2026 unless a final rule takes effect before it files that annual report; under the proposed transition, status is reassessed as of the fiscal year-end before the effective date, and relief applies from the next filing. The proposing release provides no interim relief.

Source: SEC Release 33-11419, pp. 43 to 48, 87 to 89, 114 to 116, 149, 152 and 205; Uniqus analysis. On transition, a current large accelerated filer below $2 billion in either of the two years, or with less than 60 months of reporting, becomes a non-accelerated filer. Counts are the SEC’s estimates on calendar 2024 data.

Eight decisions for SOX program leaders

1

Confirm filer status under both rule sets.

Compute public float at the last two second-quarter ends on today’s single-day basis and on the proposed 10-trading-day average, and confirm the months of reporting history.

2

Plan on the current rules if the company crossed a threshold at June 30, 2026

Three commenters asked for interim relief, but the proposal offers none. Relief for fiscal 2026 would come only if a final rule takes effect before the company files, so the effective date warrants monitoring.

3

Identify who else relies on the attestation.

A bank with $5 billion or more of assets stays under the FDIC’s rule even if its holding company is exempt. In the governance survey, 97% named investor expectations and analyst coverage among the factors that would most influence whether they use the new accommodations, and 65% debt or equity offering requirements; lenders, rating agencies and major holders are worth consulting first.

4

Base the saving on a fee proposal rather than the SEC’s average.

Ask the auditor what the audit would cost without an opinion on internal control; seven audit firms told the SEC the financial statement audit would absorb part of the work.

5

Take the decision to the audit committee with evidence.

That means material weaknesses and restatements in the last three years, finance turnover, system changes under way and the shareholder base.

6

Define the evidence standard for an assessment no one else will test.

Scope, sample sizes, tester independence and deficiency evaluation should be documented, as the auditor’s work papers will no longer provide them.

7

Decide how to explain the choice.

Beyond the cover-page check box, the proposal requires no statement on whether an attestation was obtained, though five commenters asked for one. An answer should be ready for the first investor who asks.

8

Preserve what is hard to rebuild.

This includes control documentation, information technology (IT) general control evidence and trained staff. A company whose float stays at or above $2 billion for two consecutive years is back in scope (see the example in Section 2).

7.1 Retain, discontinue, or replace

Option When it may fit What is given up
Retain the integrated audit voluntarily A recent material weakness or restatement; a planned capital raise; lenders that require it The full cost saving
Discontinue it and rely on management’s assessment Stable business and systems; a clean control record; concentrated ownership Independent testing of management’s conclusion
Replace it with a scaled alternative A program that seeks independent challenge, from internal audit or a periodic external review, without an annual opinion Simplicity, since the alternative must be designed and explained

7.2 Relying on management’s assessment alone

The second option carries a recognized risk. An advisory firm that does not audit told the SEC that without the external attestation “the 404(a) process tends over time toward formalism – “check-the-box” documentation of controls whose operating effectiveness has not been rigorously tested.” (p. 3). The American Accounting Association’s Financial Reporting Policy Committee, citing a 2017 study of small companies, adds that SOX 404(a) alone “only results in the discovery and disclosure of about half of issuers with ineffective internal controls” (p. 7).

The auditor’s work With the attestation Without the attestation
Understanding of controls Required Still required, for the design and implementation of relevant controls
Testing whether controls operate Required, to support an opinion on internal control Where the auditor relies on controls or cannot obtain enough evidence without them
Deficiencies the auditor finds All deficiencies in writing to management; significant deficiencies and material weaknesses also to the audit committee Significant deficiencies and material weaknesses still in writing to both; lesser deficiencies at the auditor’s discretion
Opinion on internal control Public, in the annual report None
A material weakness that management has not reported The auditor must say so in its report Communicated in writing to management and the audit committee; no public report
Officers’ certifications The chief executive officer (CEO) and chief financial officer (CFO) certify they have disclosed significant deficiencies and material weaknesses to the auditor and the audit committee Unchanged; the certification becomes the main formal check on what management discloses

Source: SEC Release 33-11419, pp. 61, 62 and 139; PCAOB AS 2110, AS 2301 (including paragraph 17), AS 1305 (paragraphs 4 and 7) and AS 2201 (paragraphs 78 to 81); Exchange Act Rules 13a-14 and 15d-14.

Discontinuing the attestation does not remove the auditor from internal control. The substance of the change lies in the last two rows: management’s conclusion becomes the only public conclusion on internal control, so the evidence behind it must stand on its own.

Cross-border implications:

Foreign private issuers.

A foreign company that lists in the US on Form 20-F remains subject to the auditor’s attestation from $75 million of worldwide float unless it is an emerging growth company, although it may switch to domestic forms to obtain the relief. A domestic filer of the same size would be exempt up to $2 billion.

Already held to similar rigor at home.

Some issuers already face an auditor’s report on internal control in their home market, so the US attestation largely duplicates work they do anyway. For example, in India, the auditor reports on internal financial controls for listed and most unlisted companies under Section 143(3)(i) of the Companies Act, 2013, which also means a US parent that discontinues its attestation may still have an Indian subsidiary whose auditor reports every year. In Japan, listed companies have filed a management report on internal control audited by external auditor since 2008 (“J-SOX”).

Most exposed to the gap.

Other issuers have no comparable requirement at home, so the US attestation is often the only outside opinion on their controls, and they keep it while domestic US peers may drop it. Canada relies on CEO and CFO certification under National Instrument 52-109, with no auditor’s attestation. In the United Kingdom, from financial years beginning on or after January 1, 2026, the board declares whether material controls are effective, on a comply-or-explain basis, with no auditor’s opinion. Issuers in this group feel the gap most: they keep an attestation that domestic peers below $2 billion may drop, without a home-market requirement that would have demanded similar work anyway.

In our view, a group reporting in more than one of these markets should build one control framework to the most demanding requirement it faces, rather than to the US minimum.

 

How Uniqus Can Help

Our Governance, Risk & Compliance (GRC) practice helps companies design, test, and sustain internal control. For a company that will remain a large accelerated filer, or an emerging growth company in its first five years, the proposal does not change the SOX program.

Internal controls design and testing

For a company relying on management’s assessment alone

SOX, internal financial control (IFC), and internal control over financial reporting (ICOFR) programs. Control design and management testing, scoped and documented in line with the SEC’s 2007 guidance, so the SOX 404(a) conclusion rests on its own evidence; one framework for groups reporting in more than one market.

Internal audit

For a company replacing the attestation with a scaled alternative

Independent challenge without an annual opinion. Risk-based internal audit under applicable auditing standards, covering financial, IT, and AI controls, with periodic reviews the audit committee can rely on.

Risk, compliance and governance

For boards and audit committees

Oversight that does not depend on the auditor. Enterprise risk frameworks, risk appetite and key risk indicators, compliance obligation registers, board and committee charters, delegation of authority and business continuity.

Risk UniVerse

For every option, including a retained attestation

Our AI-enabled GRC platform. Centralizes controls data and workflows, automates control testing, and turns walkthrough recordings into process narratives, flow diagrams and risk and control matrices.

Topics in this article

Related

Early Impressions

The Customer’s Customer

The FASB proposes to clarify when payments made on behalf of a customer, or to a customer of the entity’s customer, should be treated as consideration payable to a customer and therefore reduce revenue. Our early read of the proposed...

Uniqus Insights

When capacity becomes a lease

THE QUESTION Picture two companies buying GPU capacity from the same cloud provider. One signs up for a reserved cluster, paying a fixed monthly fee on a one-year term. The other pays as it goes, drawing on-demand capacity with no...

Uniqus Point of View

Building the Agentic Enterprise

EXECUTIVE SUMMARY From systems of record to a system of outcomes. An artificial intelligence (AI) agent is software that can pursue a goal, decide its next step, and act inside enterprise systems, within limits that people set. That last part...

Download the pdf of this publication


This will close in 0 seconds